The indirect effects of cytomegalovirus infection: mechanisms and consequences

14 - 15 October 2024 09:00 - 17:00 The Royal Society Free Watch online
Register now
Under a magnification of 25X, and using immunofluorescence microscopy, this photomicrograph revealed the presence of the cytomegalovirus (CMV) antigen.

Discussion meeting organised by Dr Tom Yates and Dr Helen Payne. 

Cytomegalovirus (CMV) is common. The term ‘indirect effects’ describes a statistical excess of cardiovascular disease, non-CMV infections, and other pathology seen in people with CMV absent histological evidence of CMV-associated tissue damage. This meeting will bring together laboratory scientists, paediatric and adult clinical academics, epidemiologists and trialists, to discuss the latest research on indirect effects, from mechanisms to clinical significance.

Attending the meeting

This meeting is free to attend and intended for researchers in a relevant field.

  • Both virtual and in person registration is available. Please register via Eventbrite
  • Lunch is available on both days of the meeting and is optional. There are plenty of places to eat nearby if you would prefer to purchase food offsite

Enquiries: please contact the Scientific Meetings team.

Organisers

  • Tom Yates

    Dr Tom Yates, University College London, UK

    Tom Yates is a specialist registrar in infectious diseases and general medicine. He holds an MSc in Epidemiology from LSHTM. His doctoral research was on the epidemiology and control of Mycobacterium tuberculosis in high burden settings, particularly South Africa. His UCL affiliations are with the Institute of Health Informatics and the Division of Infection and Immunity. Before joining UCL as a clinical lecturer, Tom worked at Imperial College London (2018-21), the KEMRI-Wellcome Trust Research Programme in Kilifi (2016), Africa Centre (now part of AHRI) in KwaZulu-Natal (2013-14) and at Oxford Vaccine Group (2010-11). Tom was an Associate PI for the RECOVERY Trial. Tom's research currently focuses on quantifying the indirect effects of cytomegalovirus (CMV) infection.

  • Helen Payne

    Dr Helen Payne, Imperial College London, UK

    Dr Helen Payne is a Clinical Lecturer at Imperial College London, dividing her time between research, teaching and working clinically as a registrar in Paediatric Infectious Diseases and Immunology at St Mary’s Hospital in London. She is also an honorary Clinical Lecturer at Stellenbosch University.

    Dr Payne’s research interests are in congenital infection, co-infections and understanding the role of immune activation in driving or inhibiting infections. The theme of her current work is exploring the host-immune response to cytomegalovirus (CMV) in infants and immunosuppressed children and young people, and she is running several studies within this theme.

Schedule

Chair

Hermione Lyall

Hermione Lyall, Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust, UK

Sarah Rowland-Jones

Professor Sarah Rowland-Jones, Oxford University, UK

09:00-09:05 Welcome by the Royal Society and lead organisers
09:05-09:30 Joining the dots: maternal HIV, CMV, and the placenta

Elucidating mechanisms that disrupt immune homeostasis at the maternal-foetal interface (MFI) can provide a link between HIV and CMV coinfection in pregnancy with abnormalities to infant immunity, especially children HIV exposed but uninfected (CHEU). Vertical transmission of HIV has been mitigated by the successful implementation of antiretroviral therapy (ART) either prior to or during pregnancy. Despite this, the incidence of adverse birth outcomes and the co-morbidities in newborn CHEU remains significantly higher than in infants born to HIV uninfected mothers. It is hypothesised that the immune status of mothers during pregnancy impacts on the placenta and how this in turn impacts on the immune status of the newborn neonate. We are investigating cohorts of pregnant women on different regimens of ART and different birth outcomes, such as pre-term birth and low birth weight, and measuring how placental macrophages (Hofbauer cells, HBC) and T cells change with HIV/ART exposure and impact on T cell clonality in the first 9 months of life. We show that Factor XIIIA1 expression on HBC in term placentas is significantly lower when the birth outcome is pre-term, with levels of expression being dependent on the timing of ART initiation: before or after conception. Clonality of T cells is more oligoclonal in the HEU infant relative to controls with an absence of clones predicted to recognize common viral antigens, including to CMV. Data will be shown that supports our hypothesis that the HIV-and CMV-associated maternal environment during gestation leaves a footprint in the placenta which determines the immune status of HEU newborns.

Professor Clive Gray, University of Cape Town, South Africa

Professor Clive Gray, University of Cape Town, South Africa

09:30-09:55 The relationship between maternal CMV viraemia during pregnancy and health outcomes of children in rural Zimbabwe

Children in many sub-Saharan African settings are at risk of poor outcomes in early childhood, including infectious morbidity and mortality, and growth and neurodevelopmental impairment. The reasons are likely multifactorial but include antenatal early life exposures. The First 1000 Days refers to the period from conception through 2 years of age; a child’s body, brain and immune system grow and develop during this period, and each may be critically affected by infections including HIV and CMV. In a birth cohort from rural Zimbabwe, children born to mothers with HIV had a higher risk of mortality and growth and developmental impairment compared to children born to mothers without HIV. It was hypothesised that CMV co-infection may have mediated these increased risks. Maternal CMV viraemia during pregnancy was independently associated with infant mortality amongst children who were perinatally exposed to HIV but not amongst children who were born to mothers without HIV. Amongst children who survived, neurodevelopmental outcomes were poorer amongst those born to mothers with CMV viraemia during pregnancy compared to those without exposure to CMV viraemia, regardless of maternal HIV infection. In summary, exposure to CMV may be one explanation for an increased risk of infant mortality and neurodevelopmental delay in high HIV-burden settings. By adulthood, CMV infection is almost ubiquitous in sub-Saharan Africa, and CMV frequently reactivates during pregnancy, particularly in the context of maternal HIV infection; these findings may therefore have important public health implications.

Dr Ceri Evans  University of Liverpool, UK

Dr Ceri Evans University of Liverpool, UK

09:55-10:20 Immune profile in early infant CMV

In low- and middle-income countries, early acquisition of CMV is almost universal, with the majority of infants acquiring CMV in the first year after birth. Infants with CMV infection have a distinct immune profile characterised by an activated, differentiated T-cell pool. Whether this immune activation associated with CMV is consequential remains uncertain. CMV acquisition may be more likely in infants who are exposed to HIV, or living with HIV, and CMV may act as a cofactor in disease progression. This talk will review the epidemiology of congenital and acquired CMV in LMIC settings; the immune footprint left by the virus; and the clinical consequences of early-life CMV infection in infants with and without HIV exposure.

Dr Andrew Prendergast, Queen Mary University of London, UK

Dr Andrew Prendergast, Queen Mary University of London, UK

10:20-10:45 Predicting the outcome of congenital and post-natal cytomegalovirus infections: the urgent search for biomarkers in the emerging era of universal congenital CMV screening

Congenital cytomegalovirus (cCMV) infection is the most common infectious cause of childhood disability. Most infants with cCMV have a prognosis for normal outcomes, but up to 20% will have disabilities, including sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL). Infants without clinical findings of CMV disease are still at risk for these consequences of congenital infection, but in spite of a complete diagnostic evaluation, including blood tests, ophthalmologic and audiologic evaluations, and neuroimaging, disease categorisation is challenging. This observation raises the question of whether there are heretofore undetected indirect effects of infection that might be contributing to neurodevelopmental injury. Driven by Minnesota’s new initiative for universal cCMV screening, other states in the US and provinces in Canada are adopting universal newborn screening for cCMV. There is therefore an urgency to identify biomarkers of infection that correlate with enhanced risk for long-term CMV disease. Toward the goal of addressing unmet need, the Schleiss laboratory leveraged a unique collection of ~25,000 newborn saliva samples, collected in a universal cCMV screening study performed in Minnesota that compared the diagnostic sensitivity of saliva and dried blood spot (DBS) PCR. Saliva and DBS PCR identified a prevalence of cCMV of 0.35% (87 total cases). Using the stored saliva swabs, comparisons of the salivary microbiome and proteome from cCMV+ and control infants demonstrated that the microbial community in cCMV- control infants clustered stably and consistently away from cCMV+ infants. Infants with cCMV demonstrated, by 16S rDNA analysis, dramatic alterations in the salivary microbiome. Proteomic comparisons of the two groups further suggested cCMV infection was associated with altered salivary expression of host immune response proteins. These observations suggest that cCMV, through both direct and indirect effects, has a dramatic impact on shaping neonatal microbial ecology, with a possible ensuing impact on neurodevelopmental outcomes.

Mark R Schleiss, University of Minnesota Medical School, USA

Mark R Schleiss, University of Minnesota Medical School, USA

10:45-11:10 Break
11:10-11:35 CMV/HIV coinfection in perinatally infected children in sub-Saharan Africa: lung disease and immune ageing
11:35-12:00 Respiratory syncytial virus

Respiratory Syncytial Virus (RSV) is a common cause of severe paediatric bronchiolitis. Previous studies have shown that replication of RSV in the airway is linked with an increased risk of colonisation by bacteria such as the pneumococcus and Haemophilus influenzae. Less well known is the impact of RSV infection on other common childhood viral infections. We conducted a longitudinal surveillance study in RSV-naïve Kenyan infants, who were recruited just prior to the local RSV season and sampled intensively over the course of the season in order to track the natural cause of infection. We conducted deep shotgun metagenomic sequencing to determine how kinetic changes in RSV viral load correlated with the broader airway microbiome and virome. We found that primary RSV infections were frequently followed by an increase in CMV viral load which often persisted beyond the initial RSV infection. We hypothesised that this rise in CMV was the a result of an incidental upregulation of the cell surface receptor of CMV in airway epithelia (NRP2) that was triggered by the host innate immune response to RSV. To confirm this,  we recruited a separate cohort of children who had been admitted to hospital with pneumonia and tracked them through the course of infection in order to determine whether NRP2 was selectively expressed in the nasopharyngeal epithelia of RSV-infected children. Using flow cytometric analysis, we found that RSV-infected children had a significantly higher frequency of NRP-2 positive goblet cells relative to RSV-negative children. We conclude that RSV replication in the airway increases the risk of CMV replication through the selective upregulation of the cell surface receptor for CMV on airway epithelia.

Professor Charles Sande, KEMRI-Welcome Trust, Kenya

Professor Charles Sande, KEMRI-Welcome Trust, Kenya

12:00-12:20 Facilitated discussion about the limitations of research in children, and what further studies are needed
12:20-12:50 Keynote: Vaccinating against CMV and its indirect effects

Vaccines against cytomegalovirus have been in development since the 1970s, but their use has been inhibited by both biological complexity and scientific unknowns. The target populations would be women before pregnancy in order to protect future fetuses, and recipients of solid organs or bone marrow transplants. Prevention against both primary and recurrent infection would be desirable. Experimental CMV vaccines have been developed using attenuated strains; inactivated CMV proteins such as gB, pentamer, and pp65 protein; vectored CMV proteins, and more recently mRNA. Efficacy has been demonstrated for many of these approaches but has been moderate. Vaccine composition may vary according to the target population, and whether antibody or T cell responses are preferred. It appears clear that a CMV vaccine is feasible, but the composition may vary with intended use, and may not be better than the partial protection produced by prior infection.

Stanley A Plotkin, University of Pennsylvania, USA

Stanley A Plotkin, University of Pennsylvania, USA

Chair

Paul Griffiths

Paul Griffiths MD DSc FRCPath Emeritus, University College London, UK

Professor Nathan Ford

Professor Nathan Ford, World Health Organisation, Switzerland

13:40-14:05 Human cytomegalovirus and endothelial dysfunction

Cardiovascular disease (CVD) is the global leading cause of mortality. Persons living with HIV (PLWH) are particularly susceptible to endothelial dysfunction, significantly amplifying the risk of CVD. This study aims to investigate the potential contribution of cytomegalovirus (CMV) to the pathogenesis of CVD, focusing on its effects on endothelial movement as a measure of function and endothelial nitric oxide synthase (eNOS) expression. To this end, ex-vivo experiments were conducted using a primary human arterial endothelial cell line (HAECs). Time-lapse imaging was used to track endothelial movement and quantify function in the presence of metabolic pathway inhibitors (glucose and oxidative phosphorylation) and after infection with a recombinant CMV-expressing red fluorescent protein (RFP) for enhanced visualization. 

Recombinant CMV.RFP infection significantly increased eNOS expression and superoxide in HAECs. Moreover, cell tracking analysis demonstrated decreased total distance travelled by HAECs after infection with CMV compared to uninfected cells over 24 hours. However, all other aspects of endothelial cell movement, including persistence and rate of movement, were unchanged by CMV infection.

In conclusion, an increase in eNOS/superoxide may indicate oxidative stress mechanisms are activated, contributing to endothelial dysfunction manifested by decreased movement, which may be important in endothelial homeostasis. While this study used one laboratory strain of CMV, additional studies of molecular pathways using different CMV strains may provide insights into the pathophysiology of CVD, particularly in high-risk populations such as PLWH. Further research will elucidate the underlying mechanisms and potential therapeutic strategies for targeting CMV-associated endothelial dysfunction.

Celestine N Wanjalla, Vanderbilt University Medical Centre, USA

Celestine N Wanjalla, Vanderbilt University Medical Centre, USA

14:05-14:30 CMV mismatch and health outcomes following kidney or liver transplant, a systematic review

People living with cytomegalovirus are likely to differ from people who are uninfected. Differences in baseline immune function, social contact patterns and socioeconomic position are expected and cannot easily be measured or accounted for in observational analyses. 

Deceased donor solid organ transplant offers a useful natural experiment, as the overwhelming determinant of whether recipients acquire CMV is the serostatus of their donor. In this context, confounding is a tractable function of the organ allocation algorithm, which allows cautious causal inference. 

In this session, Tom will share results from a systematic review of observational studies describing the association between donor-recipient CMV mismatch and post-transplant health outcomes in kidney and liver recipients. The focus is on all-cause mortality. The review follows the approach advocated in the COSMOS-E guidelines.

Dr Tom Yates, University College London, UK

Dr Tom Yates, University College London, UK

14:30-14:55 Interactions between CMV and respiratory viruses

CMV increases the risk of bacterial and fungal infections in immunocompromised patients. However, there is limited data on the impact of CMV on respiratory virus infections. This presentation will review the evidence of a possible interaction of CMV and respiratory viruses. Specifically, Dr Boeckh will address whether CMV increases the risk of respiratory virus acquisition and progressive infection as well as adaptive immune responses.

Michael Boeckh, Fred Hutchinson Cancer Center, USA

Michael Boeckh, Fred Hutchinson Cancer Center, USA

14:55-15:20 Break
15:20-16:15 CMV viraemia as a potentially modifiable risk factor to improve outcomes in adults with advanced HIV disease
  1. AMBITION CMV results 
  2. CICAS CMV results or TB/CMV data from Ug
  3. Caleb Ug data / other?
  4. Jarvis – time for an RCT
Professor Joseph N Jarvis, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, UK

Professor Joseph N Jarvis, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, UK

Caleb Skipper, University of Minnesota, USA

Caleb Skipper, University of Minnesota, USA

Dr Jayne Ellis, London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, UK

Dr Jayne Ellis, London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, UK

16:15-16:40 The effect of CMV on ‘inflammaging’

Cytomegalovirus (CMV) is a widespread herpesvirus that establishes lifelong latency in the human body. Emerging evidence suggests that CMV significantly impacts the aging immune system, a phenomenon often referred to as "inflammaging." This presentation will explore the intricate relationship between CMV and inflammaging, highlighting how chronic CMV exacerbates systemic inflammation and accelerates immunosenescence. We will discuss the underlying mechanisms, including CMV-driven alterations in immune cell function and cytokine profiles, with a particular focus on individuals with HIV. Understanding the role of CMV in inflammaging can reveal potential therapeutic targets to mitigate its deleterious effects on health span and longevity.

Sara Gianella Weibel MD, University of California San Diego, USA

Sara Gianella Weibel MD, University of California San Diego, USA

16:40-17:00 Facilitated discussion about the limitations of research in immunocompromised adults, and what further studies are needed

Chair

Frank Coblens

Professor Frank Cobelens, Amsterdam University Medical Center, Netherlands

blank avatar

Professor Helen Fletcher, Johnson & Johnson, UK

09:00-09:30 Keynote: Cytomegalovirus as a viral adjuvant for immune function across the life course

Herpesviruses are present throughout the vertebrate lineage, and it is likely that the great majority of members of the Homo Sapiens species were, or will become, infected with cytomegalovirus during their lifetime. 

CMV replication in controlled by sustained immune surveillance and the virus elicits arguably the largest virus-specific immune response that has been identified to date. This metabolic investment is so large that the CMV serostatus of an individual is broadly identifiable by the scale of the overall memory T cell pool within blood. The major clinical complications of CMV are seen following infection within immune suppressed individuals and the considerable burden from primary fetal infection is clearly sufficient to warrant development of an effective vaccine. 

The scale of the CMV-specific immune response is so large that there has been concern that this may impair the immune response to heterologous infection and accelerate immune senescence. Indeed, there is considerable evidence to support this concern. However, CMV infection can also impact positively on immune function and act to attenuate risk from other virus-associated conditions. 

Most humans acquire CMV infection very early in life where it acts to markedly enhance the cytotoxic profile of the peripheral immune system, a feature that may act to support pathogen control. Studies across the early phase of the life course have shown that CMV infection can boost the immune response to vaccine challenge. Vaccine studies in children have also revealed that the virus acts to temper the detrimental impact of other persistent infection. This latter observation is notable given the epidemiological evidence that CMV infection reduces the relative risk of multiple sclerosis, a condition now acknowledged to be strongly associated with EBV infection. These studies do not preclude the potential for CMV to impact negatively on immune function in the latter phases of the life course. 

As such, a case can be made that CMV has evolved the capacity to support immune function in the reproductive phase of life. The impact, however subtle, of a CMV-seronegative legacy for Homo Sapiens following the implementation of effective vaccination is of interest.

Professor Paul Moss OBE, University of Birmingham, UK

Professor Paul Moss OBE, University of Birmingham, UK

09:30-09:55 CMV and incident tuberculosis in young children

Dr Martinez will go over the current available empirical data supporting a relationship between CMV and tuberculosis, discuss open questions and data gaps, and present published and unpublished data on this topic from the Drakenstein Child Health Study, a birth cohort from Cape Town, South Africa.

Leonardo Martinez, Boston University School of Public Health, USA

Leonardo Martinez, Boston University School of Public Health, USA

09:55-10:20 CMV infection in a paediatric TB cohort
10:20-10:50 Break
10:50-11:15 Cytomegalovirus infection is a risk factor for tuberculosis disease but not tuberculosis infection

Evidence exists of human cytomegalovirus (HCMV) and immune activation as risk factors for tuberculosis (TB) disease. It is not known whether other herpes viruses are also implicated, nor if a dose-response relationship exists between TB risk and herpes co-infection.

This work describes a nested case-control study which used stored serum samples from 25 TB cases up to 10 years prior to TB diagnosis from a rural Ugandan cohort. Case and matched control samples were investigated for Epstein Barr (EBV), Herpes Simplex (HSV), and HCMV-specific IgG, serum markers of inflammation, and mycobacterial antibody levels. HCMV IgG, but not EBV or HSV was associated with increased risk of active TB disease up to 10 years prior to diagnosis. Individuals with medium HCMV IgG were 2.8 times more likely to have TB, and those with high HCMV IgG 3.4 times more likely to have TB (p=0.006). Mycobacterial antibody levels were not associated with differences in odds of TB disease. IP-10 was independently associated with increased odds of TB; OR 4.2, p=0.009. These data provide evidence of a dose response between magnitude of HCMV IgG with risk of TB disease. An inflammatory environment, characterized by serum IP-10 and IL1α, are independently associated with increased risk of TB disease.

Dr Lisa Stockdale, University of Oxford, UK

Dr Lisa Stockdale, University of Oxford, UK

11:15-11:40 Impact of human cytomegalovirus viremia on the progression of TB disease among people with HIV on long-term ART

The use of ART has led to a remarkable reduction in mortality and has improved life expectancy of people with HIV (PWH), yet TB remains a leading preventable cause of death among PWH. 

Recent evidence indicates that the spectrum from TB infection to TB disease is including a continuum of stages reported as TB infection, incipient TB, subclinical TB and TB disease. Identification of such high-risk individuals who will develop active TB in the near future would be beneficial in terms of contract tracing and TB preventive therapy. There is increasing evidence showing the link between HIV and TB, TB and HCMV, and likely the 3-way interaction between HIV, TB and HCMV. 

The temporal relationship of acquisition of HCMV and subsequent development of TB disease has been investigated in previous studies in which the majority of participants were HIV-negative.

Dr Gatechompol will present the result from a nested case-control study within a Thai HIV cohort. This study aims to evaluate whether HCMV viremia could predict the occurrence of active TB disease over a period of 6-24 months among virally suppressed PWH in long-term ART cohort.

Sivaporn Gatechompol, Mahidol University, Thailand

Sivaporn Gatechompol, Mahidol University, Thailand

11:40-12:05 Investigating causes of mortality in adults hospitalised with HIV associated tuberculosis: the role of CMV infection
Dr Charlotte Schutz, University of Cape Town, South Africa

Dr Charlotte Schutz, University of Cape Town, South Africa

12:05-12:25 Facilitated discussion about the limitations of CMV: TB research, and what further studies are needed

Chair

Charlotte Warren-Gash

Charlotte Warren-Gash, London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, UK

blank avatar

Professor John Sinclair, University of Cambridge, UK

13:25-13:50 Can supressing CMV replication delay tumour progression in glioblastoma?

Glioblastoma is an incurable brain tumour with very poor prognosis. The 2-year survival is 15%–26% and the median overall survival (OS) time is 12–14 months. Only marginal improvements in survival rates have been observed over the past decades, regardless of the treatment strategy evaluated in clinical trials. In fact, since the latest standard treatment was introduced in 2005, over 450 trials have been conducted, and only two, treatment with electrical fields and dendritic cell therapy, have shown any positive effect on survival. Söderberg-Naucler´s team previously treated 139 patients with glioblastoma with valganciclovir, which targets cytomegalovirus (CMV), and observed that these patients have a substantially longer survival time. CMV can enhance tumour aggressiveness and is found in almost all glioblastoma tumours. Among 102 patients with primary glioblastoma, 49% of valganciclovir-treated patients were alive at 2 years, compared with 18% of control patients2 (n = 231). Median OS was 24.1 months and extended to 29.7 months in optimally treated patients (VIGAS2 protocol), as compared with 13.5 months in controls (p = 0.0001). Twenty-nine patients with recurrent glioblastoma also benefitted from valganciclovir treatment; their 2-year survival was 23.1% compared with 6.7% among control patients (p = 0.0156)3. The median OS was 15.8 months vs. 8.3 months in the controls (p = 0.0083). Antiviral therapy could prevent radiation induced clinical reactivation of CMV occurring in 42% of patents and prohibited early recurrencies. Hence, valganciclovir can possibly more than double the life expectancy of patients with glioblastoma at 2 years after diagnosis.

Cecilia Söderberg-Naucler, Karolinska Institutet, Sweden

Cecilia Söderberg-Naucler, Karolinska Institutet, Sweden

13:50-14:15 Indirect effects of cytomegalovirus in depression

A subgroup of individuals with major depressive disorder (MDD) displays low-grade systemic inflammation that co-occurs with impaired adaptive immunity. Given that inflammation and stress-induced beta-adrenergic signalling can lead to cytomegalovirus (CMV) reactivation we hypothesised that CMV may act as a pathological co-factor in psychiatric disorders. Published results show an association between CMV infection and brain abnormalities (reduced grey matter volume and white matter microstructural changes) in depressed individuals as well as increased expression of inflammation-linked genes and more activated microglia in the prefrontal cortex in postmortem samples from people with mood disorders and schizophrenia. In an RNAseq study, we examined the relationship between CMV infection and gene expression in peripheral blood mononuclear cells from 60 individuals with MDD and 60 healthy controls. Preliminary analyses indicate that CMV-positive subjects showed increased activity of both classical and non-classical monocytes but no difference in interferon response factor (IRF) or NF-kB signalling pathways. Higher CMV titer was associated with increased NF-kB activity but decreased IRF activity, perhaps reflecting poorer control of the infection. If CMV reactivation drives inflammation that negatively impacts brain structure, this raises the question of whether treatment with anti-viral medication could be therapeutic for people with depression. In a pilot clinical trial, 16 individuals with MDD were randomized (1:1) to 8 weeks of treatment with valganciclovir (900mg/day, PO) or placebo to evaluate antidepressant efficacy. Blinded preliminary analyses suggest a small effect in favour of “Group A” but the direction of this effect remains to be determined.

Dr Jonathan Savitz, Laureate Institute for Brain Research, USA

Dr Jonathan Savitz, Laureate Institute for Brain Research, USA

14:15-14:40 Exploring interactions between human cytomegalovirus and immunological and clinical responses to checkpoint immunotherapy

The relationship between the development of metastatic malignancy and infection with human cytomegalovirus (HCMV) is poorly understood. Data from solid organ transplant registries indicates HCMV infection is associated with reduced rates of certain malignancies including Non-Hodgkin’s Lymphoma in organ recipients. Furthermore, analysis of tumour infiltrating lymphocytes has demonstrated that the majority of T cells found within cancers express T cell receptors conferring reactivity to viral antigens, with HCMV forming a key source of antigen for these bystander T cells.

Metastatic melanoma forms the archetypal immunosensitive cancer and shows relatively high response rates (up to 60%) to combination anti-PD1 and anti-CTLA-4 checkpoint immunotherapy. These treatments have transformed clinical outcomes such that approximately 50% of patients with metastatic disease survive for beyond 5 years post initiation of treatment.

The Oxford Cancer Immunotherapy Response Observational Study (OxCIROS) incorporates a cohort of >420 patients receiving checkpoint immunotherapy for cancer for which we have developed high resolution immune-phenotyping at serial timepoints across treatment. These data are integrated with clinical outcome enabling identification of immune correlates of response and toxicity to immunotherapy. I will describe new work demonstrating a complex relationship between HCMV status and metastatic melanoma in this cohort.

Professor Benjamin Fairfax, University of Oxford, UK

Professor Benjamin Fairfax, University of Oxford, UK

14:40-15:10 Break
15:10-15:35 Diminished Anti-HCMV T cell functionality and antibody neutralisation efficacy in the elderly resulting in virus replication at peripheral sites

Human cytomegalovirus (HCMV) infection and periodic re-activation is, generally, well controlled by T-cell responses in the healthy. In older people, overt HCMV disease is not generally seen despite the association of HCMV with increased risk of mortality; there is evidence from studies of unwell aged that it is an important co-morbidity factor. Detection of HCMV genomes in urine of older people suggest that, although the immune response retains functionality, immunomodulation due to lifelong viral carriage may alter its efficacy. In a previous study, they demonstrated that there were no age-related expansions of T-cell responses to HCMV or increase in latent viral carriage with age and these T-cells were effective, as viremia was very rarely detected. 

More recently they have shown that there is a decrease in the efficacy of the adaptative immune response (total PBMC and T-cells sub-populations) to control viral infection and spread using a Viral Dissemination Assay (VDA) in the elderly cohort. In addition, they have also demonstrated for the first time, a diminished HCMV neutralisation capacity of sera from the older donors. qPCR analysis for HCMV in blood, saliva and urine in the cohort, detected viral genomes in saliva samples, only from older donors and these donors had a defect in cellular control of viral spread in their in vitro assay. 

They now have evidence that there is increased expression of inhibitory ligands HLA-E, B7-H3 and PD-L1 on fibroblasts from older donors and preliminary evidence that disrupting the PD-1:PD-L1 axis improves control of HCMV infection in vitro VDA. They are currently investigating the balance between co-stimulation and inhibitory signalling as a driver for poor T cell control.

Mark Wills, University of Cambridge, UK

Mark Wills, University of Cambridge, UK

15:35-16:00 Impact of CMV infection on heterologous vaccine responses

Advanced age is accompanied by a decline of immune functions, which may play a role in increased vulnerability to emerging pathogens and low efficacy of vaccinations in elderly people. However, its precise determinants are not fully understood. In particular, it is yet unclear at which level age-intrinsic mechanisms and external factors (namely the co-infections with persistent viruses) cooperate, contributing to immunosenescence.

The talk will aim at reviewing current evidence on the age-dependent interplay between the host immune system and herpesviruses which are widespread among the general population: HSV-1, EBV and, in particular, CMV. To this aim, different cohorts of donors stratified by age and serological status for common latent herpesviruses will be considered and compared for the capacity to mount competent vaccine-specific humoral T and B cell responses in primo-vaccination clinical trials. To better understand the role of CMV on the induction of immunity heterologous vaccines, the quantity and quality of vaccine-specific responses will be analysed in respect to individual cellular and humoral immune parameters.

Data suggest a prevalent effect of CMV infection mainly on CD4+ naive T cells. Consistently, CMV seropositivity is associated with blunted CD4+ T-cell and antibody responses to primary vaccination. This phenomenon is observable also in younger adults, but it is not generalisable to different vaccines.

Professor Francesco Nicoli, University of Ferrara, Italy

Professor Francesco Nicoli, University of Ferrara, Italy

16:00-16:25 The efficacy and safety of CMV suppression in immunocompetent patients needing intensive care

Cytomegalovirus (CMV) is a latent herpesvirus that can reactivate in 15-40% of immunocompetent patients with critical illness from a variety of causes. In observational studies, CMV reactivation is associated with worse clinical outcomes including higher mortality and longer duration of mechanical ventilation. CMV could plausibly cause worse clinical outcomes through one or multiple mechanisms: first, as a result of direct cytopathic injury; second, as a result of systemic or tissue-level inflammatory responses; third, as a contributor to secondary bacterial or fungal infections. The core question is whether CMV contributes to worse clinical outcomes or is a bystander, which can only be answered by randomised controlled studies examining the use of antiviral therapy. Small interventional trials have examined the role of antiviral prophylaxis or therapy among critically ill patients with CMV reactivation. Together these have suggested a higher number of ventilator-free days (VFDs) among patients who received antiviral therapy but no impact on mortality, however, studies have generally been limited by size and heterogeneity. The results of a well-powered clinical trial of pre-emptive ganciclovir use among patients with CMV reactivation, sepsis, and acute respiratory failure are forthcoming.

Hannah Imlay, University of Utah, USA

Hannah Imlay, University of Utah, USA

16:25-16:45 Facilitated discussion regards the limitations of research in immunocompetent adults and the elderly, and what further studies are needed
16:45-16:50 Concluding remarks by lead organisers
Dr Tom Yates, University College London, UK

Dr Tom Yates, University College London, UK

Dr Helen Payne, Imperial College London, UK

Dr Helen Payne, Imperial College London, UK